Jake Oresick always suspected that his days at Schenley High School were sort of unusual.

“At Schenley, I felt like I experienced reverse peer pressure,” says Oresick, who grew up in Highland Park and went to Schenley in the ‘90s. “I remember someone laughing at someone who was gay, and he was confronted about it by this big, tough football player. It was the opposite of everything you’d expect. There was a strong social influence to be kind and tolerant. You got to be yourself and know that you were doing the right thing.”

It wasn’t until he began writing a history of the school, The Schenley Experiment (Penn State University Press), that he noticed how this unofficial ethos was pretty consistent throughout the school’s tumultuous 156-year history. Many of the hundreds of Schenley grads and faculty he interviewed had similar stories.

“This sort of culture that existed in the ‘90s; there were definitely manifestations of that in every decade,” says Oresick. “People might not have defended gay people in the ‘20s and ‘30s but they were doing something similarly revolutionary for the time.”

Even going back more than a hundred years to its predecessor, Central High School, it was a cosmopolitan place, welcoming students of many races, classes and backgrounds. In a segregated city, it was known for the many languages spoken in its halls and for electing minorities to class leadership positions (even as the teachers’ ranks remained all white until the 1950s).

The school’s controversial closure in 2008 came as a shock to Oresick, as it did to many alumni. It was part of sweeping changes initiated by Pittsburgh Public Schools Superintendent Mark Roosevelt to address funding shortfalls. The expense of asbestos removal was the official reason cited, which is still disputed by Schenley advocates.

The building was recently converted to 180 luxury apartments, with the first residents moving in this July.

“If the school hadn’t been closed, this book wouldn’t have happened,” says Oresick, an attorney. “It was a constructive mourning process for me. Only one chapter deals with the closing and deals with it in very precise detail. I didn’t know what I was going to find.”

Cover image courtesy of Penn State University Press

The Schenley Experiment is more than the story of one school. It’s also a window into the educational history of Pittsburgh as it adapted to waves of industrialization, immigration, civil rights struggles and backlashes. Oresick found that the school was at the forefront when it came to educational innovation and social change—sometimes, way out front.

“Something really different and interesting was happening in every decade,” says Oresick. “At every phase, they were trying something bold and innovative that people didn’t necessarily want to do. The newspapers were saying, ‘We hope it closes,’ and that it’s ‘an expensive public humbug.’”

The school itself predates the iconic Oakland building—Oresick traces it back to the city’s first public school, Central, founded in a rat-infested Smithfield Street storefront in 1855.

The aptly-named first principal, James Noble Rule, believed the modern school should “foster community and ‘functional equality’ across social strata.” Its construction went way over budget in 1916—from $600,000 to $1.4 million—making it one of the most expensive schools ever built.

Anytime big things were happening in the 20th century, Schenley grads seemed to be there.

To give just a few examples, there was Jacob Rothschild (’27), a rabbi and key ally to Martin Luther King Jr. on civil rights whose Atlanta synagogue was bombed in retaliation for his civil rights work. Clifford Shull (’33) won the Nobel Prize in physics for developing a molecular probing technique that “helped answer where atoms ‘are.’” Derrick Bell (’48) was the first Black tenured Harvard law professor, described by Barack Obama as “the Rosa Parks of legal education.” Ivan Getting (’29), a child of Slovak immigrants, helped devise a microwave fire-tracking system to shoot down German V-1 rockets during World War II and became co-creator of the Global Positioning System (GPS).

Schenley also taught Andy Warhol (’45), the “father of modern jazz piano” Earl “Fatha” Hines and wrestling legend Bruno Sammartino (’55). Pulitzer Prize-winning novelist Willa Cather (My Antonia, O Pioneers!) was a teacher.

Schenley’s clout took a nosedive in the ‘70s, however, as the steel industry went into terminal decline and “white flight” eroded its advantages.

Then, a series of pedagogical reforms spearheaded by superintendent Richard C. Wallace—including an ambitious teacher training center and three rigorous magnet programsreinvigorated the school, even bringing it national attention.

“The book focuses on a lot on the school’s reboot in 1983,” says Oresick. “It was a school with a poor reputation—the students were almost all African-American and poor. It had been failing, and students and teachers were trying to transfer away. The state was going to step in and forcibly integrate it.”

“To create the Teacher Center—every teacher, for 10 years, was there by choice,” says Oresick. “That created a remarkable environment, and they were involved in the recruiting. They’d go to Highland Park and talk nervous 8th graders into attending.”

Schenley’s student body was a powerhouse in things as different as basketball and theater. Partnerships with institutions like Pittsburgh Ballet Theatre were common.

“Everyone I went to college with was from a small, mostly white suburb,” says Oresick. “Knowing someone from another neighborhood or town was a big deal. I had a friend who said, ‘I don’t believe you. I don’t believe you had three professional ballerinas in your class.’”

Oresick observes that after it closed, plaster at Schenley was tested.  “Only trace amounts of asbestos” were found.

A science classroom more than six years after the building was closed, 2014. Photo: Cooper Miller.
A science classroom more than six years after the building was closed, 2014. Photo: Cooper Miller.

For Oresick, the seedling for The Schenley Experiment, which is his first book, may have grown in his DNA. “My father [Peter] was an author and poet, and he loved Pittsburgh history,” says Oresick. “He’d tell me all these stories and facts about every place we went and, as a kid, I didn’t care. Then, it came up on me all at once.”

Oresick will be discussing the book May 8 at the Carnegie Library Lecture Hall in Oakland at 6 p.m. Admission is free.

“I wanted people to tell their own stories,” he says. “Instead of an author talk, there will be a panel discussion with four Schenley teachers who had been there for 92 years combined.”

He’ll be joined by Schenley teachers Carol Dyas (1983-2000), Fred Lucas (1972-2000), Carol Sperandeo (1970-2005) and principal John Young (1979-1991).

Michael Machosky

Michael Machosky is a writer and journalist with 18 years of experience writing about everything from development news, food and film to art, travel, books and music. He lives in Greenfield with his wife, Shaunna, and 10-year old son.